Town of Holly Springs
Board of Commissioners Regular Meeting
Tuesday, June 5, 2001

MINUTES

The Holly Springs Town Board of Commissioners met in regular session on Tuesday, June 5, 2001 in the Town Board meeting chambers, located in Town Hall, 128 S. Main St. Mayor Parrish L. Womble presided, calling the meeting to order at 7:42 p.m. A quorum was established as the mayor and all five board members were present as the meeting opened.

Board Members Present: Commissioners Tim Sack, John Schifano, Chet VanFossen, Peter Atwell and Hank Dickson and Mayor Womble.

Board Members Absent: None.

Staff Members Present: Carl G. Dean, town manager; Ernest C. Pearson, town attorney; Joni Powell, town clerk (recording the minutes); Stephanie Sudano, director of engineering; Gina Bobber, director of planning and zoning; Drew Holland, finance director; Jennifer Carr, director of economic development; and Katie McDonald, environmental engineer. Len Bradley, director of parks and recreation, arrived at 8:10 p.m.

2 and 3. The pledge of allegiance was recited, and the meeting opened with a moment of silent meditation.

4. Agenda Adjustment - The June 5, 2001 meeting agenda was adopted with changes, if any, as listed below.

Motion By: Dickson
Second By: Atwell
Vote: Unanimous
Items Added to Agenda: None.
Consent Agenda Items Moved to New Business: None.
Other Changes: None.

5a. Public Hearing: FY 2001-02 Budget - Mr. Dean had explained in Agenda Notes that the subject budget of the public hearing represents his recommended budget with adjustments directed by the Board of Commissioners during the May 22 budget workshop: speed control devices for Cayman Avenue have been added; a contribution to the SPCA for its new animal shelter has been added; and revenues and expenditures have been adjusted to reflect the slightly higher garbage collection rates to facilitate the option of having Holly Springs garbage exported to Sampson County by Waste Industries.

Mr. Dean explained that the purpose of the public hearing is to give citizens a chance to provide comments on the budget. He added that during the week the budget had been available for public inspection (and so advertised), but there were few inquiries.

Mayor Womble opened the public hearing. No comments were offered.

There being no comments, the public hearing was closed.

5b. Public Hearing: Ordinance 01-12 - Ms. Bobber explained that the subject zoning ordinance proposal was requested by the Town Board and would add modular or manufactured temporary public office units as a permitted use in the Town Center Mixed Use zoning district.

Ms. Bobber explained that existing permitted uses in the TC-MU District include public buildings and offices; however, the Zoning Ordinance specifically calls out temporary modular offices as a specific use and does not include them as a permitted use in the TC-MU District. She added that the amendment was prepared to allow the Town to place temporary modular or manufactured offices in this district during renovations to the existing Town Hall.

Ms. Bobber reported that the Planning Board reviewed the amendment and suggested that permits would need to be renewed after two years so as to ensure that the building is "temporary" and does not become "permanent."

With that explanation completed, Mayor Womble opened the public hearing and no comments were offered for or against the zoning amendment proposal.

There being no comments, the public hearing was closed.

6a. Ordinance 01-10: FY 2001-02 Budget Ordinance - Mr. Dean explained that adoption of Ordinance 01-10 would put into place the FY 2001-02 town operating budget, along with its supporting revenues and fees.

Covering the basic points of the budget ordinance, Mr. Dean reported that the General Fund balances at $8,373,475 while the Utility Fund balances at $5,042,650. The General Fund would be funded, in part, by a 53-cent advalorem tax rate applied to the Town's tax base and assuming a 98% collection rate.

He said the spending plan features a 3% cost of living adjustment for all town employees and members of the Board of Commissioners, and a merit program and longevity pay is included in the salary sections of the budget. Mr. Dean pointed out that the Town also included a $25 contribution toward each employee carrying dependent health care coverage to help offset this year's premium rate increase.

Following the budget workshop on May 22, Mr. Dean said, the proposed budget was further adjusted as directed by the Board. Added to expenditures were speed control devices to be installed on Cayman Avenue; a $10,000 contribution to the SPCA for its new animal shelter on Tryon Road; and a change in the garbage and recycling service fees to $12 per household per month, which will allow the Town to transport its garbage to Sampson County beginning July 1.

Commissioner Sack asked that when the Town makes its contribution to the SPCA that an agreement be drawn stating that Holly Springs would be allowed to use the facility for the housing of animals when needed.

Commissioner Atwell asked Mrs. Sudano to explain how would the $30,000 in the Engineering Department's professional services line item be spent. She explained that the line item provides for professional services tied to projects that are unexpected but come up during the year.

Commissioner VanFossen asked if the Town Manager had considered a reduction in the water rates. Mr. Dean said when staff looked at adjusting the rates, staff considered the Town's considerable debt service, and feels it would be difficult to lower the rates at this time. Mr. Dean suggested that the Town examine the idea next year after the Town has had an opportunity to determine how much usage will be through the Harnett line and whether or not the Town can afford to lower the rates and still meet its financial obligations.

Commissioner VanFossen asked if improvements to the intersection of Hwy. 55 and Holly Springs Road are included in the budget. Mrs. Sudano explained that money is included in the budget for design of intersection improvements, and that NCDOT has indicated it would provide "safety funds" for construction if the Town were to provide the design.

Action: The Board approved a motion to adopt Ordinance 01-10 setting the FY 2001-02 Town Budget and setting the fiscal year's rates and fees, and planned revenues and expenditures.
Motion By: Schifano
Second By: Atwell
Vote: Unanimous
A copy of Ordinance 01-10 is incorporated into these minutes as addendum pages. A copy of the FY 2001-02 budget will be maintained throughout the fiscal year in the Town Clerk's office.

6b. Ordinance 01-11 - The Board approved a motion to adopt Ordinance 01-11, a separate ordinance setting the water and sewer rates for FY 2001-02.

Motion By: Sack
Second By: Atwell
Vote: Unanimous
A copy of Ordinance 01-11 is incorporated into these minutes as an addendum page.

6c. Ordinance 01-12: Allowing Modular Units in TC-MU -The Board approved a motion to adopt Ordinance 01-12 to allow public temporary modular or manufactured units in the Town Center Mixed Use zoning district with the addition of the words "with Zoning Permit renewal required after two (2) years"

Motion By: Atwell
Second By: VanFossen
Vote: Unanimous
A copy of Ordinance 01-12 is incorporated into these minutes as addendum pages.

6d. Flood Plain Letter - Mrs. McDonald explained to the Board that the State of North Carolina, through a partnership with the Federal Emergency Management Agency, has been designated as the first Cooperating Technical State (CTS). As a CTS, the State of North Carolina will assume primary ownership and responsibility of the Flood Insurance Rate Maps (FIRMs) for all North Carolina communities as part of the National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP), she said.

As a result, the State is undertaking a project that will include conducting flood hazard analyses and producing updated, digital FIRMs. She said the current status of the State flood mapping program as it relates to Holly Springs is the Final Basin Plans for the Neuse and Cape Fear River Basins, which will be published in the near future, and the work to re-study the flooding sources will begin shortly.

Mrs. McDonald added that Wake County is currently leading an initiative to have a layer of flood plain information prepared based on future build-out conditions across the County. FEMA's standards for flood insurance and FIRMs require that flood plain mapping be prepared based on current land cover/use. However, because of the rapid pace of growth in Wake County, and especially in Holly Springs, significant increases in both the area and flood elevations associated with the 100-year flood have occurred each time there has been a new flood study, Mrs. McDonald explained. She added that Town staff agrees with Wake County staff and other professionals that this will continue to happen with this update unless a layer of the flood plain mapping is based on proposed build-out conditions as depicted in the Town's 10-Year Comprehensive Growth Plan.

Mrs. McDonald said staff is requesting that the Town Board authorize a letter be sent to Mr. John Dorman, allowing Holly Springs to join Wake County and other local governments in petitioning the CTS committee to include future build-out conditions in the current flood mapping projects in the Neuse and Cape Fear River Basins.

Commissioner Schifano asked if the Town's 10-Year Plan could me amended or if using the Plan in the mapping would somehow prevent future amendments to the Plan. Mrs. McDonald explained that the 10-Year Plan could be amended at any time, but that the Town would have to keep in mind that the mapping layer may not be as accurate. She said a mapping layer with the 10-Year Plan incorporated, even if it changes, would be better than a map with no development build-out taken into consideration at all.

Action: Following Mrs. McDonald's presentation, the Board approved a motion to authorize a letter requesting that the Holly Springs 10-Year Comprehensive Growth Plan be used in the State's flood plain mapping project in the preparation of a layer on the map.
Motion By: Schifano
Second By: Dickson

6e. 01-ZPF-03: Sunset Spring Apartments - Ms. Bobber explained that the applicant is proposing to construct a 2-story, 9,960-square-foot apartment building designed for elderly residents. The project is anticipated to contain 40 units (32 one-bedroom and 8 two-bedroom units). Each unit would have one or two bedrooms, a full kitchen and living room. Common areas would include multi-purpose rooms and lounges, a library and laundry facilities, she added.

Since this project is located within the Arbor Creek Planned Unit Development, it is subject to all requirements of the Arbor Creek PUD Master Plan, Ms. Bobber noted, adding that the Master Plan calls for this portion of the development (between Firefly Road and Commons Drive along Sunset Lake Road) to contain a maximum of 50 multi-family units. Multi-family in the Arbor Creek PUD is defined as townhomes, apartments or assisted living units.

Since the Arbor Creek PUD Master Plan does not provide for specific lot dimensional criteria for multi-family residential developments, this project is being reviewed using the Town's Multi-Family District and dimensional requirements, Ms. Bobber said.

She explained that this site is upstream of several areas that have drainage concerns. The plan has included detention of run-off as part of the site, and the detention pond has been designed to handle a 23-year storm.

The plans as submitted meet all general zoning and engineering requirements, Ms. Bobber said, adding that the applicant has requested to pay a fee-in-lieu-of dedication of open space for this project.

Ms. Bobber reported that the Planning Board had reviewed the plan and recommends approval with conditions. She said staff also recommends approval with conditions.

Action:After discussion, the Board approved a motion to approve Zoning Permit for Sunset Spring Apartments, 01-ZPF-03 as submitted by Sunset Spring Housing Associates LLC, Project Number ECC-00001, dated Revised 5-7-01 subject to the developer's satisfying the following (4) conditions/staff review comments and (/) additional conditions imposed by the Board of Commissioners:
  1. If upon inspection by the Department of Planning & Zoning once site clearing and grading is complete, additional plantings may be required to be provided in the perimeter buffers to meet the Town's landscape requirements. The contractor is to schedule inspection upon completion.
  2. Please provide a sealed engineer's estimate for the items you are requesting a fee-in-lieu for in the format shown in the attached example.
  3. Payment of fee-in-lieu of dedicating open space in the amount of $650/unit is to be provided upon application for building permit.
  4. Construction drawings and erosion control drawings must be approved prior to construction's beginning. The following (2) items are to be included on construction drawings (later in the approval process):
    1. The Town is evaluating the implementation of a "Middle Creek Bridge fee-in-lieu-of-assessment." Note that lots developed as part of this plan would be subject to such fee if it were adopted.
    2. Improvements to the downstream pump station will be required to support this and other development. Financial participation based on flow would be required.
      1. If the natural undisturbed 30-foot buffer is indeed disturbed, the site plan will come back to the Board for further review and instructions as to replacement of vegetation and buffers.
      2. Landscaping will be required around the detention pond, and a grass basin will be required.
      3. Fencing should be installed around the perimeter of the detention pond bank.
Motion By: Schifano
Second By: Atwell
Vote: Unanimous

6f. Request for Fee Waiver - Mr. Lyle Gardner of Evergreen Construction Company and the developer of the Sunset Spring Apartments project requests that the Town waive certain development fees for his project. Mr. Gardner said he was attempting to keep the cost as low as possible on the units and that the Town's participation would assist.

Mr. Dean reported that department heads and he all recommend - for various reasons - that the Town Board opt to not waive any fees on this development project.

Commissioners expressed concern that the Town's operating budget is based on fees it collects from development, and that the Town depends on these fees to pay debt service for improvements.

Commissioner Atwell summarized that the Board wants to see the apartments developed in Holly Springs, but cannot, at this time, waive fees.

Mr. Gardner asked if the Board would consider a loan on the project. The Board directed that Mr. Gardner bring back a proposal for its consideration. Mr. Gardner also asked if certain fees on the list could be adjusted to reflect the impact that elderly residents would pose. For example, Mr. Gardner asked if the parks and recreation fees required could be eliminated or reduced since elderly residents would not likely use the Town's facilities and programs as much as younger residents.

The Board suggested Mr. Gardner prepare a proposal of fees he would be willing to pay and those he would like to have adjusted for the Board's consideration.

Action: The Board approved a motion to deny Mr. Gardner's current request for waiver of development fees.
Motion By: Dickson
Second By: Atwell
Vote: Unanimous

6g. 01-ZPF-04: Carolina Architectural Woodworks Inc. - Ms. Bobber explained that the applicant is proposing to construct a 13,200-square-foot light manufacturing, architectural woodworking company on Lot 10 in the Holland Industrial Park. This would be the first company to locate in this new phase of the development on Tradition Trail. All operations for this company would be indoors. The building has been placed on this site to allow for future expansion of the building or subdivision of the lot, Ms. Bobber said.

The plans as submitted meet all general zoning and engineering requirements; however, there is a conflict between the Statement of Design Compatibility and the Architectural Drawings in regard to the brick color that is be used for the building, Ms. Bobber said. The Statement of Design Compatibility states that the brick will be brown, and the Architectural Drawings indicate a gray color brick. She said this item is required to be resolved prior to the issuance of a building permit.

Staff and the Planning Board recommend approval with conditions, Ms. Bobber reported. Staff requests the addition of the condition relating to the color of the brick since it was not resolved at the Planning Board meeting.

During discussion, the Board indicated it would not be necessary for the plan to be brought back to the Town Board for a decision on the color of brick.

Action: The Board approved a motion to approve Zoning Permit 01-ZPF-04 for Carolina Architectural Woodworks Inc. as submitted by Bass, Nixon & Kennedy, Project Number 01131000, dated Revised 5-7-01 with the following (1) condition:
  1. Construction drawings and erosion control drawings must be approved prior to the beginning of construction on this site.
Motion: Sack
Second: Schifano
Vote: unanimous

7. Head Start - Mr. Bradley presented results of a study that has been completed regarding charges for space paid by Head Start in other locations. From the information received, it would appear that the Town of Holly Springs is in the average range for lease charges, unless the square footages vary significantly, Mr. Bradley said.

He suggested that, should the Board consider raising the fees for this lease, staff would recommend no more than a 30% increase for each room and that the existing 50% of shared utility bills remain the same.

Currently, the Town receives $150 per classroom per month for each of seven classrooms it uses in the Hunt Center. Additionally, the Town receives $200 per month for use of the cafeteria. Head Start also pays for half the utilities in the building.

Action: The Board approved a motion to institute an increase in the rental rates of $50 each per classroom, office and cafeteria for Head Start.
Motion By: Sack
Second By: Schifano
Vote: Unanimous

8. Consent Agenda - All items on the Consent Agenda were approved following a motion by Commissioner Dickson, a second by Commissioner Atwell and a unanimous vote. The following actions were affected:

8a. Ordinance 01-13 - Ordinance 01-13 was adopted to add two members to the roster structure of the Holly Springs Parks and Recreation Advisory Committee, as recommended by the Committee.
A copy of Ordinance 01-13 is incorporated into these minutes as an addendum page.

8b. Parks Committee Appointments - The Board appointed residents Marky Williams and Peg Kelley to the Holly Springs Parks and Recreation Advisory Committee, as recommended by the Committee.

8c. Minutes - Minutes of the Board's regular meeting held on May 15 and then continued in budget workshop on May 22, 2001 were approved.

9. Public Comment - At this time, the Board opened the floor to those in the public who wished to address the Board on any variety of topics not listed on the agenda. The following comments were offered: None

10. Other Business: Mr. Pearson reported that a contempt of court appearance relating to the Don Davis zoning violation case is set for July 2. He said results of the hearing may result in the closing of Davis' business and the owner's being placed in jail on charges of contempt of court. Mr. Pearson also reported that Mr. Hood has been found in contempt in his zoning violation case, but that he could purge himself of that contempt if he were to present the court a presentable plan on Monday.

11. Manager's Reports: Mr. Dean thanked staff for their assistance during the budget preparation process.

12. Closed Session - The Board approved a motion to go into Closed Session, pursuant to G.S. 143-318.11(a)(3), to discuss pending lititgation, particularly the Wake County vs. Holly Springs matter; and pursuant to G.S. 143-318(a)(5), to discuss the acquisition of real property.

Motion By: Sack
Second By: Atwell
Vote: Unanimous

General Account Closed Session - June 5, 2001

Mr. Dean brought up the subject of the possibility of the Town's purchasing the former Mako Trucking site in the industrial park for use a Public Works facility and over-flow Town Hall space. He pointed out that the investment would be a sound one for the Town because whatever price the Town paid for the property, it would be able to recoup with profit upon sale of the property in the future. He asked the Board's direction to proceed with pricing negotiations for further consideration by the Town. He was given that direction.

Mr. Pearson provided information to the Board regarding the landfill litigation case, specifically as it concerns to Wake County's negative response to the Town's request to allege "negligent" misrepresentation rather than "fraudulent" misrepresentation. Mr. Pearson advised that the Town abandon the misrepresentation angle entirely and focus on police power arguments instead.

Action: The Board approved a motion to return to open session.
Motion By: Schifano
Second By: Atwell
Vote: Unanimous
- End of General Account

Adjournment - There being no further business for the evening, the June 5, 2001 meeting of the Holly Springs Board of Commissioners was adjourned at 10:08 p.m. following a motion by Commissioner Schifano, a second by Commissioner Atwell and a unanimous vote.

Respectfully Submitted on Tuesday, June 19, 2001,


Joni Powell, CMC
Town Clerk
Addendum pages, as referenced in these minutes, follow and are a part of the official record of this meeting.